Rancher viewpoint diversity in human–wildlife coexistence management: The case of jaguar–livestock interaction in the region of Calakmul, Mexico

Abstract

[ES] Las áreas protegidas de América Latina suelen estar rodeadas de paisajes ganaderos, donde grandes carnívoros como el jaguar conviven con ganaderos, lo que puede provocar interacciones negativas. Sin embargo, es crucial reconocer que la coexistencia efectiva depende del desarrollo de políticas de conservación que no sólo aborden estas interacciones negativas, sino que también abarquen la diversidad de perspectivas de los terratenientes, alineándose con las preferencias de las comunidades para prevenir conflictos de conservación. El artículo revela que las preferencias de los ganaderos son diversas. Algunos favorecen el aumento de la cubierta forestal y la ganadería silvopastoril, mientras que otros prefieren la reducción de la superficie forestal y la ausencia de jaguares. Por lo tanto, los incentivos a la conservación deben diseñarse de forma que respondan a las necesidades fundamentales de las comunidades locales, como la educación, la sanidad, la capacitación de las mujeres y la preservación cultural. Los diagnósticos participativos en los que intervengan las comunidades locales son imprescindibles para identificar con precisión estas necesidades. [EN] Protected areas in Latin America are typically surrounded by ranching landscapes, where large carnivores such as the jaguar (Panthera onca), co-habit with ranchers, which potentially causes negative interactions. It is crucial, however, recognize that effective coexistence hinges on developing conservation policies that not only address these negative interactions but also embrace the diversity of the landowners' perspectives, aligning with the preferences of communities to prevent conservation conflicts.In this study, we conducted discrete choice experiments (DCE) with 196 ranchers in five localities in the Calakmul region to assess their preferences about four key attributes related to jaguar conservation: percentage of forests, livestock management practices, the number of desired jaguars and the willingness to invest in measures that promote coexistence between livestock and jaguars.Our research reveals that ranchers' preferences are diverse. Some favour increased forest cover and silvopastoral ranching, while others prefer reduced forest areas and the absence of jaguars. To address these diverse viewpoints and promote positive preferences, we must develop a comprehensive strategy considering the full spectrum of needs and preferences.Therefore, conservation incentives must be designed to address local communities' fundamental needs, such as education, healthcare, women's empowerment and cultural preservation. Participatory diagnostics involving local communities are imperative to accurately identify these needs. The observed heterogeneity of preferences in our study emphasizes the importance of integrating these diverse perspectives into conservation policies for a more balanced and equitable distribution of resources.Our findings demonstrate the value of DCEs in providing valuable information for developing more effective and socially acceptable jaguar conservation policies that consider diverse perspectives and the people's characteristics in our sample population.